The state health insurance marketplaces that opened Oct. 1 give consumers who are looking for coverage on the individual market a whole new way to shop for health plans. At the same time, health insurance brokers and insurers will also continue to sell plans directly to customers. Sorting out who’s selling what can be confusing.
What's more, some brokers and insurers will not just sell policies that are outside the marketplaces. They may also offer marketplace plans and their customers may be eligible for subsidies for those marketplace plans. While shoppers can find good coverage going any of these routes, the plans and services offered may differ in important ways.
The Affordable Care Act has fundamentally changed the market for individual health insurance. In the past, insurers held nearly all the cards. In most states, they could turn applicants for coverage down if they had even minor pre-existing medical conditions. The plans that were offered typically failed to cover common conditions such as pregnancy, and insurers generally faced few restrictions on the premiums they charged.
Starting in January, the individual market – including policies sold on the marketplaces and outside them -- will become much more consumer-friendly and consistent. Insurers will no longer be allowed to deny coverage to people who are sick, and premiums will only be permitted to vary based on a few factors, including age, tobacco use, family size and where someone lives. Every individual plan will have to cover a set of 10 comprehensive "essential health benefits," including maternity and newborn care, hospitalization and prescription drugs, among other things.
Instead of myriad cost-sharing options, consumers will pick from four plan types: bronze plans will pay for 60 percent of medical expenses, silver plans will pay for 70 percent, gold plans 80 percent and platinum plans 90 percent. The maximum amount people will be on the hook for out-of-pocket will be capped at $6,350 for individuals and $12,700 for families.
Whether someone shops on the state marketplaces, also called exchanges, or outside them, these elements will be consistent among all plans starting in January. The major difference between plans sold only outside the marketplaces by brokers and insurers and those that have been vetted and approved by a state exchange is that only exchange plans will make health law subsidies available to people with incomes up to 400 percent of the federal poverty level ($45,960 for an individual and $94,200 for a family of four in 2013). But while marketplaces will sell only exchange plans, some brokers and insurers will sell both subsidized exchange plans and standard, non-subsidized individual market plans.
Brokers help consumers drill down for detailed plan information about participating providers and covered benefits, among other things, says Susan Rider, an independent insurance broker with Gregory & Appel Insurance in Indianapolis.
"Just because a plan covers autism benefits, it might not cover the specific benefits I need," she says. "A consumer may not know to ask, but that's where brokers come in."
Still, consumer advocates say they’re concerned that brokers or insurers may not direct consumers first to all the exchange plans for which they could receive a subsidy to reduce their costs.
"I'd encourage anybody looking for a plan to go first to the exchange website and get a full sense of the range of options that are there," says Sabrina Corlette, project director at Georgetown University’s Center on Health Insurance Reforms.
Insurance brokers and insurers who want to sell exchange plans must undergo training in order to do so. They typically receive a commission on plans that they sell for which they have an agreement with the insurer. That happens for both plans sold on and off the exchange. Brokers that sell marketplace plans on the Internet must at a minimum provide consumers with the names of every available exchange plan. Other brokers don't have to present all exchange plan options to consumers.
"They can steer people to the plans that they're affiliated with and presumably know more about," says Jennifer Tolbert, director of state health reform at the Kaiser Family Foundation (KHN is an editorially independent program of the foundation.) "It’s not a reason for people not to use a broker, but it's important for people to understand."
Likewise, consumers who go directly to an insurer's website will see all the exchange plans it offers, as well as a link to the marketplace, where they can see all exchange plans available from other insurers.
However, consumers might fail to consider all their options because they'd see just a single insurer's plans first, says Cheryl Fish-Parcham, deputy director of health policy at Families USA, an advocacy group.
In addition to their expertise, there may be other reasons to consider shopping with a broker or insurer. For one thing, not all insurers are represented on the exchanges; in some cases the number may be very limited. Consumers who want to buy a policy from a particular insurer may need to shop outside the marketplace.
And for people whose income is close to or exceeds 400 percent of the federal poverty level, "it may not be worth the hassle of filling out the subsidy application and maybe changing your carrier and your provider," says Carrie McLean, director of customer care for ehealthinsurance.com, an online web broker that has been authorized to sell exchange plans in the 34 states in which the federal government is running the exchanges or partnering with the states. "That's going to be important for consumer choice."
Please send comments or ideas for future topics for the Insuring Your Health column to email@example.com.